Data story · November 16, 2026 · Data as of November 16, 2026
COPD VA claims: burn pits, the PACT Act, smoking and what the Board grants
How the Board of Veterans' Appeals decides COPD claims: the PACT Act burn pit presumption for Southwest Asia and Afghanistan service, the tobacco rule and the route through PTSD, why the Agent Orange list does not help, how VA rates COPD, and the conditions claimed with it.
Where VA presumes the link
Is COPD presumptive for burn pit exposure?
Yes, since the PACT Act took effect in August 2022. Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease is on the burn pit list with chronic bronchitis and emphysema, and it is presumed service connected whenever it appears after qualifying service (38 U.S.C. 1120; M21-1 VIII.ii.2.A). Qualifying service is the Southwest Asia theater of operations, Somalia and the other listed places since August 1990, or Afghanistan, Djibouti, Syria, Uzbekistan and the other listed places since September 2001; the exposure itself is presumed. Before the PACT Act, the burn pit regulation covered asthma, rhinitis, sinusitis and some rare respiratory cancers, but not COPD. In decisions that name burn pits or other airborne hazards, the Board granted 30.5% of COPD claims (273 of 895), against 13.2% overall.
All COPD claims
Burn pits or other airborne hazards
Iraq
Kuwait
Afghanistan
Saudi Arabia
Any covered place
No covered place named
Agent Orange or other herbicides
Share of decided claims granted; a remand counts as not granted. One count per veteran. Each row is what the decision mentions; rows overlap, and a mention is not proof of qualifying service or exposure. Covered places: the Southwest Asia theater, Afghanistan, Syria, Djibouti and Uzbekistan, plus the countries the PACT Act added.
Where did COPD claims do best?
In decisions that name a place covered by the burn pit presumption: 24.8% granted (299 of 1,204), against 11.7% where no covered place is named. By place, the Board granted 41.8% of COPD claims in decisions that name Saudi Arabia, 28.0% for Kuwait, 24.2% for Iraq and 23.2% for Afghanistan.
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
Share of decided claims granted; a remand counts as not granted. One count per veteran. Every claim kind under DC 6604. The PACT Act took effect in August 2022.
In 2020 decisions, COPD claims that named a covered place were granted 7.4%; by 2023, 37.4%. The share fell to 23.2% in 2025, a year with more of these claims than any before (293); the data does not show why. Claims that name no covered place rose more slowly, from 8.0% to 16.7%.
Smoking and the tobacco rule
Can VA deny COPD because the veteran smoked?
It can deny a claim built on smoking in service. For claims received after June 1998, a disability is not service connected on the basis that it came from the veteran's use of tobacco products during service (38 U.S.C. 1103; 38 CFR 3.300(a)). The rule does not bar a claim that rests on something else, such as a toxic exposure or a presumption, even when the veteran also smoked (38 CFR 3.300(b)). In practice, smoking mostly comes up as the other likely cause in the medical opinions. Where the decision discussed smoking or tobacco, the Board granted 10.4% of COPD claims (216 of 2,079), against 14.0% where it did not. In decisions that discussed smoking and also named a covered place, it granted 19.6% (29 of 148).
Smoking or tobacco discussed
Not discussed
Share of decided claims granted; a remand counts as not granted. One count per veteran. Found from words in the AI summary of each claim (smoking, tobacco, cigarettes, pack-years).
Only 21 claims cite the tobacco rule itself, and the Board granted 0 of them. Most claims fail on the medical question instead: for the 3,130 denied COPD claims, the Board's note named the medical link in 58.1%, the in-service event in 29.9% and the diagnosis in 14.7%. When a VA examiner blames smoking and a private doctor points to jet fuel, solvents or burn pits, the case turns on which opinion explains itself better; where the two are about equally strong, the veteran gets the benefit of the doubt.
Can COPD be secondary to PTSD through smoking?
Yes. If a service-connected condition such as PTSD led the veteran to smoke after service, and that smoking was a substantial factor in causing or worsening the COPD, secondary service connection can be granted (M21-1 X.iv.1.D.3.d; M21-1 X.iv.1.D.3.e). The opinion has to answer each step, including whether the COPD would not have happened without that smoking. This route is closed when the earlier service connection was itself based on tobacco use in service, such as nicotine dependence (38 CFR 3.300(c)). The Board granted 22 of 154 COPD claims marked secondary to PTSD (14.3%).
When the exposure is not on the list
Is COPD on the Agent Orange list?
No. COPD is not one of the diseases presumed for herbicide exposure, and it is not on the Camp Lejeune list either. In decisions that name Agent Orange or other herbicides, the Board granted 9.5% of 2,459 COPD claims, below the overall share; for Camp Lejeune it was 8.2% of 280. Those claims need a medical opinion linking the COPD to the exposure. COPD is presumed for veterans with full-body exposure to mustard gas or Lewisite in service (38 CFR 3.316).
Some exposures off the list did better than average without a presumption. In decisions that name jet fuel, the Board granted 21.1% of 261 COPD claims, and asbestos 14.8% of 1,510. These rest on a medical opinion for each veteran.
How VA rates COPD
How does VA rate COPD?
Under DC 6604 in 38 CFR 4.97, from 10 percent to 100 percent, by breathing tests: how much air the veteran can blow out in the first second, compared with what is expected and with the total, and how well the lungs pass gas into the blood. The top rating also covers heart strain from the lungs, respiratory failure and the need for oxygen at home. VA uses the results after a bronchodilator unless they are worse than before it (38 CFR 4.96(d)). COPD is not rated separately from asthma, most other lung conditions or sleep apnea: VA assigns one rating for the main condition and raises it a step when the overall disability warrants it (38 CFR 4.96(a)).
The counts follow DC 6604, which also holds chronic bronchitis and generic respiratory claims. Claims whose caption names COPD were granted 14.4% (6,614 veterans), chronic bronchitis 13.9% (1,059) and a respiratory condition with no named disease 9.6% (2,332).
Conditions claimed with COPD
What conditions are claimed with COPD?
Sleep apnea is the condition most often claimed secondary to COPD: the Board granted 13 of 57 (22.8%). Because COPD and sleep apnea share one rating under 38 CFR 4.96(a), the second grant matters when it can raise that rating (M21-1 V.iii.4.A.1.c). COPD itself is claimed secondary to asthma (25.0% granted), sleep apnea (19.6%), asbestosis (19.5%), coronary artery disease (11.5%) and diabetes (7.0%).
| COPD claimed secondary to | Granted | Veterans | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| PTSD | 22 | 154 | 14.3% |
| Coronary artery disease | 7 | 61 | 11.5% |
| Diabetes | 4 | 57 | 7.0% |
| Asthma | 12 | 48 | 25.0% |
| Sleep apnea | 9 | 46 | 19.6% |
| Asbestosis | 8 | 41 | 19.5% |
Look up your client's group
Every base, exposure, job and medal with at least 15 decided COPD claims, 103 groups in all. Burn pits and other airborne hazards, and mustard gas, are the groups that fall under a presumption.
- Bar: share of this group's COPD claims the Board granted. Red line: all COPD claims, 13.2% granted. A bar past the line won more often than usual.
- ×
- More often than usual: how much more often COPD comes up in this group's decisions than in all Board decisions. It shows how common the condition is here, not how often it wins.
- Set aside
- For groups VA does not presume, veterans whose decision shows service VA already presumes for COPD (for example Vietnam or Thailand for Agent Orange) are left out, because for them the presumption is the answer.
Fort Knox
18.2% granted · 4 of 22
1.6×more often
Fort Hood
14.3% granted · 3 of 21 · 1 with presumptive service set aside
1.1×more often
Royal Thai Air Force Base (RTAFB) in Korat, Thailand
12.5% granted · 3 of 24 · 1 with presumptive service set aside
1.1×more often
Da Nang AFB
11.1% granted · 4 of 36
1.3×more often
Fort McClellan, Alabama
10.5% granted · 6 of 57 · 1 with presumptive service set aside
1.6×more often
Fort Bragg
9.5% granted · 2 of 21 · 4 with presumptive service set aside
1.5×more often
Fort Dix, NJ
8.3% granted · 3 of 36
2.7×more often
Fort Ord
8.3% granted · 2 of 24 · 8 with presumptive service set aside
3.1×more often
Camp Lejeune
6.9% granted · 18 of 259 · 21 with presumptive service set aside
1.8×more often
Eglin AFB, Florida
6.7% granted · 1 of 15
2.4×more often
Fort Polk
6.7% granted · 2 of 30
2.4×more often
USS Midway
6.7% granted · 1 of 15
3.4×more often
USS Ranger
6.3% granted · 1 of 16
2.6×more often
Udorn Royal Thai Air Force Base, Thailand
5.3% granted · 1 of 19
0.8×more often
Fort Jackson
3.8% granted · 1 of 26 · 1 with presumptive service set aside
1.6×more often
U-Tapao Royal Thai Air Force Base, Thailand
3.8% granted · 1 of 26
0.9×more often
Fort Gordon (Eisenhower)
0.0% granted · 0 of 17 · 3 with presumptive service set aside
1.5×more often
Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri
0.0% granted · 0 of 20
2.4×more often
Kadena AFB
0.0% granted · 0 of 20
2.1×more often
Kadena Air Force Base, Okinawa, Japan
0.0% granted · 0 of 15
1.9×more often
4 more groups: too few claims to judge once veterans with presumptive service are set aside
- USS Independence: 13 of 15 claims left, 2 set aside
- USS Coral Sea: 14 of 16 claims left, 2 set aside
- Camp Casey: 13 of 15 claims left, 2 set aside
- Fort Benning: 13 of 16 claims left, 3 set aside
Read the decisions
Recent decisions, with the Board's reasoning as summarized by AI and checked against the decision text:
- , November 2025: COPD granted under the PACT Act for a veteran whose personnel records show service in Saudi Arabia in early 1991. COPD was diagnosed in 2003; with the presumption, the Board noted, no medical link was needed.
- , December 2025: COPD and emphysema granted on the burn pit presumption for Southwest Asia service; a lung nodule was denied as not a presumptive condition.
- , December 2025: COPD, bronchitis, pleuritis and sarcoidosis denied for a veteran who reported burn pit exposure in Iraq and Kuwait; the Board found none of these conditions diagnosed during the appeal.
- , December 2025: COPD denied. The veteran's only theory was smoking that began in service, which 38 U.S.C. 1103 bars; with no other link to service, VA did not have to provide an examination.
- , December 2025: COPD granted secondary to a service-connected psychiatric condition, on medical evidence that the condition caused the veteran's smoking after service and the smoking caused the COPD.
- , December 2025: COPD and emphysema granted on toxic exposures in service. A VA examiner blamed smoking; a private examiner linked the COPD to jet fuels, solvents and herbicides. The Board found the evidence about evenly balanced.
- , December 2025: COPD denied for a Vietnam veteran after a court remand. COPD is not on the herbicide list, and the Board found the VA opinion that decades of smoking were the more likely cause more persuasive.
What the data cannot tell you
The counts follow DC 6604, so they include chronic bronchitis and generic respiratory claims coded there, and every claim kind, including some rating appeals. The groups and places come from what each decision mentions; a mention is not proof of service or exposure, and a decision can fall in more than one group. Decisions that name a place only in a quote of the law are left out of the place counts. "Smoking discussed" is found from words in the AI summary of each claim and misses some; it does not say whether smoking was the reason for the ruling. Secondary counts include only claims the Board marked as secondary. These are historical outcomes, not predictions.
For representatives
- For a veteran with Southwest Asia, Afghanistan or other covered service, prove the dates and places and get a COPD diagnosis with breathing tests. The exposure and the link are then presumed.
- Do not build the claim on smoking in service; 38 U.S.C. 1103 bars it. Build it on the exposure, the presumption or a service-connected condition.
- If PTSD or another service-connected condition led to smoking after service, ask for an opinion that answers each step: the condition caused the smoking, the smoking was a substantial factor, and the COPD would not have happened without it.
- Where a VA opinion blames smoking, answer it with a reasoned private opinion on the exposure; the Board weighs the reasons, not the number of opinions.
- A veteran denied COPD before August 2022 with covered service can file a supplemental claim under the PACT Act.
- Before claiming sleep apnea secondary to COPD, check whether it can raise the single respiratory rating.
Explore the data
Read the decisions behind this story
VA Law Explorer finds the decisions, quotes the reasoning and writes a research memo.
Ask VA Law ExplorerAbout the data
Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions 2020-2025 (decoder_ring.theories, decoder_ring.presumptions, decoder_ring.secondary_history, bva_cases_v2 lead basis), diagnostic code 6604. Each veteran is counted once per condition, at the best ruling in the decision (granted, then remanded, then denied); grant share = granted / all decided, so a remand counts as not granted. 'More often than usual' compares how often the condition comes up for a group with how often it comes up across all decisions. Groups overlap and are identified from what the decision text mentions; a mention is not proof of service there or of exposure. Historical outcomes, not predictions. Queried November 16, 2026. Every figure in this story is computed from the query results, and the AI-extracted data can contain errors. The figures are fixed as of that date. Related research pages describe their own data dates and methods.
VA Law Explorer Weekly
New data stories, M21-1 and 38 CFR changes, and updates to the Board decision data, in one email a week. Free; unsubscribe anytime.
We send this newsletter only. See our privacy policy.
Where this data comes from
- Claim
- Regional office decides
- Veteran appeals
- Board decides
- Granted · Denied · Remanded: back to the regional office
Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions show how VA's highest review body applies 38 CFR and weighs evidence on contested claims.
Each one is an appeal: a regional office decided the claim first, and the veteran appealed. So these rates describe the Board, not a veteran's odds at the regional office, where most claims are decided and whose decisions are not public.
More on what Board decisions can and cannot tell you