{"page":"https://casescribe.ai/explorer/judges/d-smart","generated_at":"2026-10-03T18:29:07.732Z","data_as_of":{"decisions":944125,"first_year":2017,"last_year":2026,"latest_decision":"2026-04-30","cfr":"2026-10-01","m21":"2026-09-29"},"about":{"publisher":"CaseScribe AI (VA Law Explorer)","source":"Public Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions (appeals of VA decisions, not VA's first decisions), M21-1 Adjudication Procedures Manual, 38 CFR Parts 3 and 4.","method":"Outcomes are issue-level: each condition the Board decided in a decision counts once. Decision data is extracted by AI and can contain errors. Rates describe past appeals and do not predict any claim.","disclaimer":"For research only. CaseScribe AI is not a law firm and this is not legal advice. Verify figures against the source decisions and regulations.","attribution":"Cite as: VA Law Explorer, CaseScribe AI, with the page URL."},"data":{"judge":"D. Smart","note":"Judges do not choose their cases. Compare only with board_same_conditions_*, the rest of the Board on the same mix of conditions. Not a ranking.","decisions":3406,"years":"2019-2026","issues":6547,"granted_pct":19.5,"denied_pct":28.4,"remanded_pct":50.1,"board_same_conditions_granted_pct":20,"board_same_conditions_remanded_pct":46.9,"by_condition":[{"condition":"Knee conditions","issues":479,"granted_pct":17.3,"board_granted_pct":17.3,"remanded_pct":54.7,"board_remanded_pct":51.1},{"condition":"Hearing loss","issues":311,"granted_pct":12.9,"board_granted_pct":19.5,"remanded_pct":34.4,"board_remanded_pct":34.6},{"condition":"PTSD","issues":286,"granted_pct":32.9,"board_granted_pct":28.9,"remanded_pct":38.8,"board_remanded_pct":38.1},{"condition":"Sleep apnea","issues":269,"granted_pct":29,"board_granted_pct":26.2,"remanded_pct":53.5,"board_remanded_pct":50.3},{"condition":"Tinnitus","issues":245,"granted_pct":38,"board_granted_pct":39.6,"remanded_pct":22,"board_remanded_pct":22.8},{"condition":"Hypertension","issues":186,"granted_pct":17.2,"board_granted_pct":17.2,"remanded_pct":50,"board_remanded_pct":48.7},{"condition":"Degenerative arthritis of the spine","issues":181,"granted_pct":18.8,"board_granted_pct":20.7,"remanded_pct":58.6,"board_remanded_pct":46},{"condition":"Intervertebral disc syndrome","issues":170,"granted_pct":22.4,"board_granted_pct":18.6,"remanded_pct":48.2,"board_remanded_pct":48},{"condition":"Migraine","issues":168,"granted_pct":33.3,"board_granted_pct":30.1,"remanded_pct":44,"board_remanded_pct":42.2},{"condition":"Hip impairment","issues":153,"granted_pct":17.6,"board_granted_pct":14.3,"remanded_pct":54.9,"board_remanded_pct":53.8},{"condition":"Shoulder impairment","issues":144,"granted_pct":16,"board_granted_pct":14.3,"remanded_pct":59.7,"board_remanded_pct":53},{"condition":"Ankle impairment","issues":128,"granted_pct":10.9,"board_granted_pct":16.9,"remanded_pct":60.9,"board_remanded_pct":50.4},{"condition":"Diabetes mellitus","issues":91,"granted_pct":24.2,"board_granted_pct":19.9,"remanded_pct":41.8,"board_remanded_pct":40.1},{"condition":"Cervical spine limitation of motion","issues":88,"granted_pct":8,"board_granted_pct":13.2,"remanded_pct":64.8,"board_remanded_pct":58.3},{"condition":"Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD)","issues":72,"granted_pct":12.5,"board_granted_pct":19.3,"remanded_pct":62.5,"board_remanded_pct":52.9}],"by_year":[{"year":2019,"issues":17,"granted_pct":11.8,"denied_pct":52.9,"remanded_pct":35.3},{"year":2020,"issues":244,"granted_pct":11.5,"denied_pct":34,"remanded_pct":47.1},{"year":2021,"issues":477,"granted_pct":15.7,"denied_pct":36.9,"remanded_pct":43.4},{"year":2022,"issues":441,"granted_pct":17.5,"denied_pct":22.9,"remanded_pct":52.2},{"year":2023,"issues":2089,"granted_pct":18.5,"denied_pct":26.8,"remanded_pct":44.6},{"year":2024,"issues":2536,"granted_pct":18.8,"denied_pct":26,"remanded_pct":44},{"year":2025,"issues":2897,"granted_pct":17.8,"denied_pct":28,"remanded_pct":43.9},{"year":2026,"issues":999,"granted_pct":21.1,"denied_pct":28.7,"remanded_pct":39.1}]}}